Explore Alternatives Best of For you Guides

Explore Alternatives Best of For you Guides

Explore Search Alternatives Collection

fragr.

Every fragrance that exists — what it smells like, when to wear it, and the smartest way to buy it.

Explore

Buying guides
Affordable alternatives
Best winter fragrances
Best summer fragrances
Best date night fragrances
Best office fragrances
Recommendations for you

Fragr

About
Affiliate disclosure
Privacy
Contact

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Fragrance data is community-sourced and editorial; we are not affiliated with the brands listed. Alternatives shown are independent inspired-by compositions, not the original fragrances.

© 2026 Fragr

VIP Black Extra by Carolina Herrera — notes, seasons & similar scents | Fragr

Home
/Carolina Herrera
/VIP Black Extra

VIP Black Extra by Carolina Herrera

Carolina Herrera· 2019· Eau de Cologne

VIP Black Extra

7.919Typically ~$90

A sweet scent built around cola over cocoa. Suits daily wear in fall.

SweetFruitySyntheticGourmandCreamy

Scent profile

Top notes

Cola Grapefruit Rum

Heart notes

Black leather Lavender Moss

Base notes

Same DNA, per our similarity engine

Smells similar

212 Vip Men Black Extra 2019

Carolina Herrera· 2019

Xocoatl by Fueguia 1833

From the same house

More from Carolina Herrera

Good Girl by Carolina Herrera

Good Girl

Carolina Herrera· 2016

When to wear it

A fall fragrance that works day and night — at its best for everyday wear and date nights.

FallNightEveryday wear

When

Winter

91%

Spring

79%

Summer

71%

Fall

100%

Day

94%

Night

100%

Where

Office

71%

Casual

100%

Date

93%

Club

76%

Formal

59%

Performance

Longevitylong-lasting

Sillageroom-filling

Season & occasion fit is derived by Fragr from this fragrance’s accords and notes (100% = its strongest setting). Longevity and sillage reflect community reports.

Xocoatl

Fueguia 1833· 2010

8.1512~$350

Coffee White Flowers by Bohoboco

Coffee White Flowers

Bohoboco· 2016

Phantom Intense by Paco Rabanne

Phantom Intense

Paco Rabanne· 2024

I Love New York for All by Bond No. 9

I Love New York for All

Bond No. 9· 2011

Severo by Jacques Zolty

Severo

Jacques Zolty· 2019

Coffee Bomb

Maison Tahité· 2022

Bvlgari Man In Black Essence 2017

Bulgari· 2017

VII: Queen Anne - Cosmos Flower by Clive Christian

VII: Queen Anne - Cosmos Flower

Clive Christian· 2016

Suma Oriental

Une Nuit Nomade· 2015

Signature Grey by bugatti Fashion

Signature Grey

bugatti Fashion· 2021

Opulent Vanilla

Antiqua Firenze· 2023

212 Men by Carolina Herrera

212 Men

Carolina Herrera· 2007

8.47.2K~$90

CH Men by Carolina Herrera

CH Men

Carolina Herrera· 2009

CH Men Privé by Carolina Herrera

CH Men Privé

Carolina Herrera· 2015

212 VIP Men by Carolina Herrera

212 VIP Men

Carolina Herrera· 2011

Very Good Girl by Carolina Herrera

Very Good Girl

Carolina Herrera· 2021

Chic for Men by Carolina Herrera

Chic for Men

Carolina Herrera· 2004

212 by Carolina Herrera

212

Carolina Herrera

Bad Boy Cobalt Parfum Electrique by Carolina Herrera

Bad Boy Cobalt Parfum Electrique

Carolina Herrera

212 Sexy by Carolina Herrera

212 Sexy

Carolina Herrera· 2006

Good Girl Légère by Carolina Herrera

Good Girl Légère

Carolina Herrera· 2018

212 VIP by Carolina Herrera

212 VIP

Carolina Herrera· 2022

Sport

45%